Is Fight Club actually an updated version of The Great Gatsby? Why or why not?

Thesis: Fight Club can be considered an updated version of The Great Gatsby because the lives of both characters are influenced and ultimately destroyed by the materialism.
Body 1: The belief that the pursuit of material goods is directly connected to the pursuit of happiness.
Body 2: Jay Gatsby and the narrator are tragic heroes because both possess flaws that cause them and those around them pain; however, through this pain, they offer examples of courage and determination.
Please find quotes from only the two books: fight club and great gatsby
I can only use two sources for this paper and those are fight club and great gatsby